Thursday, July 17, 2025

The 2024 reTROview reTROspective!!!

 

It's a new record! I honestly wrote this in January and never got around to posting it, but better late than never.

This year had a lot more gaming than last year. I didn’t have to build a house, and I got a full year out of my Analogue Pocket, which allowed me to complete a ton of old, short games during a little downtime here and there. The following is a list of games that I completed in alphabetical order:

  1. Actraiser

  2. Advance Wars 2

  3. Aladdin (SNES)

  4. Animaniacs (Genesis)

  5. Battle Garegga

  6. Borderlands 2

  7. Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel

  8. Breath of Fire

  9. Bucky O’Hare

  10. Cuphead

  11. Danny Sullivan’s Indy Heat

  12. Dead Cells

  13. Dead Cells: Return to Castlevania

  14. Fire Emblem: Engage

  15. For Whom the Frog Bell Tolls

  16. Gimmick!

  17. Gran Turismo 7

  18. Kirby’s Dream Land 3

  19. Little Samson

  20. Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of Hope

  21. Mario Golf (GBC)

  22. Metal Slug 4

  23. Metal Slug 5

  24. Metal Slug 6

  25. Mickey’s Ultimate Challenge

  26. Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers

  27. Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers: The Fighting Edition

  28. MLB The Show ‘24

  29. Mother 3

  30. Ninja Gaiden II

  31. Octopath Traveler

  32. Rock ‘n Roll Racing

  33. The Simpsons

  34. Sky Blazer

  35. Super Mario Bros. Wonder

  36. The Twisted Tales of Spike McFang

  37. Tiny Toon Adventures 2

  38. Yoku’s Island Express

38 is pretty solid! A far cry from my candidly embarrassing 65 clears in 2017, but much better than the 22 from 2023.

Let’s get started with the awards! 

Honorable Mentions

These are games that weren’t quite good enough to get in the top 10, but were fun, memorable, or unique enough to warrant a mention.

Animaniacs (Genesis)

For the love of all that is holy, do not play Animaniacs on SNES. The Genesis version is very solid, though. Great homage to the cartoon, controls well, and is simple and fun. It also has the honor of being the oldest member of my backlog to be cleared this year. I used to have this on Genesis as a kid and never beat it. I have now rectified that.

Ninja Gaiden II

This gets the honor of being the hardest game I defeated this year. Absolutely brutal, and thus very rewarding. The first one is better, though.

Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers (SNES)

Games oriented towards newcomers to a genre get a bad rap from Hardcore Gamers. They shouldn’t. We all had to start somewhere! This is a very fun and polished beat ‘em up simplified for kids. It’s a great intro to the genre for children or those not quite ready to dive into Streets of Rage.

Sky Blazer

I had never heard of this game before and found it totally charming! It’s a side-scrolling action game, but you can play the levels in a variety of orders, with different rewards for each. You can upgrade your character with several new spells that feel very rewarding to play with. It also looks great and controls beautifully. This is absolutely a hidden gem on the SNES.

Dead Cells

If you haven’t played this game and enjoy Metroidvanias, give this a try! For a game that touts randomization as a core feature of the game, it feels a little vanilla after a while, but it boasts superb controls, well-thought out enemies, and an engaging gameplay loop that lets you feel absolutely unbeatable with the right mix of perseverance and luck.

For Whom the Frog Bell Tolls

Thanks to Frank Cifaldi for highlighting this one, and for the stellar retro gaming community for translating this Japanese exclusive game to English for all our benefit! It’s an R&D 1 developed puzzle game/RPG for the Gameboy, and it oozes polish and charm out of every pore. The story is cute, the gameplay is unique, and it’s one many gamers probably have not checked out.

The Twisted Tales of Spike McFang

Thanks to the Analogue Twitter account, which regularly publishes gifs of gameplay footage for featuring this one. Everybody knows the heavy hitters of SNES RPGs, but few know about this delightful little action RPG romp. You play as a tomato juice slurping vampire prince intent on reclaiming his future kingdom from the forces of evil. It’s got great graphics (seriously, this game looks as good as almost anything else on the SNES), excellent controls, fun enemy and character designs, and well-designed combat. It’s super short, too.

Danny Sullivan’s Indy Heat

Having listened to the Completely Unnecessary Podcast for years, I have heard this game referenced as an in-joke dozens (hundreds?) of times. So I finally decided to check it out on my Pocket. And I have to say that this is actually a sweet little game with great controls, graphics, and a nice car progression system that feels fair and impactful. If you like top-down racing games, check this one out.

Now for the Top 10!

10. Borderlands 2

I know, I know. How did I miss this wildly popular smash hit the first time around? The Xbox 360/PS3 era was my nadir for awareness of current developments in gaming. College was filled with mostly intramural sports and anime, with a sprinkling of playing on my PS2 and NES and SNES emulators. I didn’t even learn about HDMI until probably 2013, embarrassingly. Anyway, I played this with my brothers-in-law and son this year and had a lot of fun with it. It has a unique personality and well-designed characters and scenarios that lend themselves to a fun time for any style of player.

9. Gran Turismo 7

This game is gorgeous, with fast loading times, incredible physics, and a huge selection of cars and tracks to pick from. It also absolutely NAILS the progression cycle you’re hoping for in a game. It gives you tons of rewards for playing, but those rewards are always scaled appropriately for your current situation in the game. This one scratched every itch in my lizard brain.

8. Super Mario Wonder

Another Mario game, another spectacular experience. Nintendo’s development staff is simply the best. While this is far from my favorite Mario game, the new wrinkles they added create a lot of memorable moments and opportunities for Nintendo’s boundless creativity to shine.

7. Little Samson

This was high on my list to experience on my Analogue Pocket because I’d never played it before, and it’s so expensive to get a physical cartridge. I walked away from this game very impressed and simultaneously grateful that I didn’t spend $2,000 to buy a copy. I have crossed this one off my list to obtain…no game is worth that kind of money. But I do highly recommend playing it for the spectacle alone. Nothing on the console should be capable of looking and playing like this. I’ll be saying that again shortly for an even better game, though.

6. Mario Golf

The Mario sports games on the Game Boy family are absolutely incredible and must be experienced. I didn’t think I’d enjoy this one because I’d already played the GBA entry (among my favorite GBA games of all time) and was worried that it would feel dated. When I booted it up, though, it got its claws into me immediately. It’s very ambitious for a Game Boy Color game, with a wide variety of courses and characters to play as. I sank a ton of hours into it and will probably boot it up to play a round here or there many times in the future.

5. Bucky O’Hare

When I got my Analogue Pocket, I sorted all of the games I was downloading into buckets. I called them Bangers, Japanese, Try It, and Jetsom. This was one of the games in the Try It folder based on the name alone. I booted it up and discovered to my incredulous surprise that this is a little-talked-about late NES platformer from Konami that is incredibly impressive. Graphics, sound, and gameplay all work together to create an all-time classic NES game. Seriously, this game is so underrated. It should have a similar reputation as Little Samson but doesn’t for some reason. This is a top 20 game in an absolutely LOADED library on the NES.

4. Actraiser

Speaking of pleasant surprises, Actraiser was so great! This game is a mix of city-building sim and platformer, and while neither element quite reaches the peaks of their given genres, they’re both solid B+ efforts with a tremendous synergy between the two of them. Throw in a high degree of difficulty for melding two genres together in a coherent whole and how early this game came out in the life of the SNES, and this game gets two big thumbs up in my book.

3. Gimmick!

I hear people talk about Little Samson all the time. It has a certain cache among retro gamers that is totally earned. But Gimmick! is every ounce the technical monster that Little Samson is, and far more ambitious with gameplay experimentation. The enemies have a very sophisticated AI built into them that was unthinkable on the NES, and the complex physics engine they programmed into this game is absolutely jaw dropping. This game MUST be experienced by fans of retro games. The only knock I have against it is that it’s cruelly unfair to complete without save states, but the dedicated could probably do it with enough practice.

2. Advance Wars 2

I have a lot of nostalgia for this game, but never actually completed it. We used to take turns passing a GBA under the desk during Biology class in high school, until Mrs. Fombelle confiscated my friend’s GBA…the savagery. It’s a great hot-seat multiplayer game that also has a deep and challenging campaign. It looks great, sounds great, and is great. I think Dual Strike is still the best entry in the series, but not by much. Check it out!

1. Cuphead

I’ve been pushing this one off for years until I could get a physical copy for a reasonable price. Amazon finally put it up for $20 a few months ago, and I dove in as soon as I could. This is one of the most beautiful video games ever made, period. Its unique aesthetic stands out immediately, but it’s far more than a pretty face. They absolutely nailed the controls and design of this game. It feels great, the bosses are immaculately designed and executed, and the difficulty balance is absolute perfection. It teaches you the mechanics of the game diagetically. Learn them or you die. Many, many times. The game has several of my favorite boss battles ever. And the crazy thing is that these battles occur both as run ‘n gun platform battles as well as side-scrolling shooters. My only small complaint is that the periodic side-scroller traditional platformer levels don’t work as well as the shooter and platform boss battle parts of the game. This is an all-time masterpiece, and any fans of Mega Man or other similar retro games need to experience it.

2024 reTROview Stinker of the Year: Mickey’s Ultimate Challenge

I have worked diligently to break my bad habit of wanting to finish everything I start. The breaking point for me was years ago, trying desperately to beat Spider-Man and the X-Men in Arcade’s Revenge, when I thought “I don’t enjoy this and could play something I do enjoy, instead.” And so I did. Now, if I play a horrible game, I just turn it off. The days of me spending 40 hours trying to beat Final Fantasy IV: The After Years are long gone.

All that is to say that Mickey’s Ultimate Challenge isn’t an awful game. It’s just boring. But it was super short, and that was nice. It’s just a small handful of milquetoast mini-games that you play to beat the game. It can probably be beaten in 15 minutes easily. I’d have been grossly disappointed to get an SNES cartridge of this as a kid.

Now to revisit my 2024 goals and see how I fared!

2024 Goal #1: Fix more hardware

FAIL. I just didn’t have the money. My Gamecube remains busted. I did replace some broken PS5 controllers, though.

2024 Goal #2: Complete 30 new games

Success! I completed 38 games and really enjoyed the vast majority of them.

2024 Goal #3: Complete Breath of Fire

Success! I did it. It was pretty good.

2024 Goal #4: Complete Suikoden

FAIL. I didn’t get to it. I didn’t want to. But I’m going to do it, hopefully this year.

2024 Goal #5: 1 CC a vertical shoorter

FAIL. This was a stupid goal. Do you know how hard these are? I really tried.

2024 Goal #6: 1 CC Ghouls ‘n Ghosts

FAIL. This was an even stupider goal. Do you know how hard this game is? I beat the first level. 😊

My 2025 goal is to set better goals. Speaking of which…

2025 Goal #1: Complete Suikoden

This is up next on my list to complete after I finish Tears of the Kingdom, which I’ve been working on for 2 months. Wow. I hope my PS2 works.

2025 Goal #2: Fix Hardware

It’s gotta be done. I just got a new job that will theoretically give us some more financial flexibility, too.

2025 Goal #3: Complete 30 games

30 feels right, especially since I’ve spent so much time on Tears of the Kingdom.

2025 Goal #4: Finish all the numbered Mega Man X games

I just bought Anniversary Collections 1 & 2 and am itching to play some. I’ve beaten X through X4 already.

2025 Goal #5: Read 24 books

I do things other than play video games! I’m targeting two books per month. I can do it!

See you soon!

-TRO

Tuesday, June 4, 2024

The Subjective Scientific reTROview Console Tier List - 2024 Edition: The Console Middle Class

The middle class of consoles are all ones that I have some fondness for, but if they went away, I would probably be ok. As usual, the points are determined by having 10 points for a perfect/iconic game, 5 points for an excellent game, and 1 point for a good game. Our cutoff point comes after the Mobile phone, which was the last denizen of the I'm Pretty Sure I Should Own This tier. We pick up our coverage with the...



Xbox 360 (37 points):

Good games:
Army of Two
Bastion
Dynasty Warriors 8
Ghost Recon: Advanced Warfighter 2
Guitar Hero: World Tour
Lego Batman
Lego Batman 2

Excellent Games:
Grand Theft Auto 5
Halo 3
Lego Marvel Super Heroes
Mass Effect
Mass Effect 2
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

I probably had about 80% of my Xbox 360 experience during a brief 9 month window where I was living with my future wife's parents and me and her brother played on his a ton. I enjoyed it, but really haven't explored the console further. I tend to default to the PS3 for this generation because I adore the DualShock 3, but this may be the technical wrong answer.


Playstation 3 (37 points):

Good games:
Mega Man 9
Mega Man 10
NCAA Football
Skylanders: Swap Force
Tekken Tag Tournament 2
Batman: Arkham Origins

Excellent Games:
Batman: Arkham Asylum
Batman: Arkham City
Mass Effect 3
Ni No Kuni
Street Fighter IV
The Last of Us

Speaking of the PS3...this is my Batman machine! I really like the UI and controller on this bad boy. It had a bunch of other really good games, too. Like the 360, I've barely scratched the surface of the library to boot.

Sega Genesis (38 points):

Good games:
Castlevania: Bloodlines
Comix Zone
Disney's Aladdin
Road Rash II
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Hyperstone Heist
Vectorman
X-Men 2: The Clone Wars
Streets of Rage

Excellent games:
Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine
Gunstar Heroes
Sonic the Hedgehog
Sonic the Hedgehog 2
Sonic 3 & Knuckles
Streets of Rage 2

I sold my SNES to get a Sega Genesis, and I couldn't have made a worse mistake. Well, I guess I could have bought the Jaguar or something. Luckily, I've made up for it later on in life. However, I still love the Genesis! There's a ton to experience on this console yet - I've never done the deep Genesis library dive that I've devoted to the SNES and NES. This one may pull up in the rankings over time. 


Nintendo DS (41 points):

Good games:
Children of Mana
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance A2
Mario and Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
New Super Mario Bros.
Pokemon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum
Yu-Gi-Oh 5D's World Championsship 2011: Over the Nexus

Excellent games:
Advance Wars DS
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
Mario and Luigi: Partners in Time
Mario Kart DS
Pokemon Black/White
Pokemon Black 2/White 2
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass

Of all of the inhabitants of the Console Middle Class, this one is probably the one I've spent the most time with. A marvel of design and concept, the DS rules. Having a slot on the bottom for GBA games put the icing on the cake for me, as I could retire my old GBA and have a beautiful, backlit screen to play GBA games on instead (I had not yet been exposed to the glory of the GBA SP 101 yet). I feel like there's a lot to experience on the console yet, though. I didn't have hardly any money back then, so I didn't buy much new. Emulators for it didn't exist until somewhat recently, and I've been too busy to dive in to more than a handful of games in that fashion. Now, hard copies of a lot of the games I want are simply too expensive in the box, so I don't have a great collection of many of the vaunted RPGs on the system. This one could definitely move up. I'll get there!



Gamecube (42 points):

Good games:
Donkey Konga
Donkey Konga 2
Pikmin
Super Mario Sunshine
The Legend of Zelda: Four Swords Adventure
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
Luigi's Mansion


Excellent games:
Mario Kart: Double Dash
Mario Party
Animal Crossing

Perfect/Iconic games:
Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour
Super Smash Bros. Melee

This is the first console on this tier list to have two perfect/iconic games, and I stand behind both of them. Melee is literally my favorite video game of all time, and the Mario Golf entry on the Gamecube stands alone as the best Mario sports title, ever. It has given our family countless phenomenal hours of fun, still looks beautiful, and has incredibly designed courses. I feel like there's still a lot more to be experienced here, too. I have a bunch of Cube games I've never tried before, and if I could just get my console working properly (dead laser), I'd totally do it. Eventually.





Game Boy (43 points):

Good games:
Pokemon Trading Card Game
Pokemon Trading Card Game 2
Super Mario Land
The Final Fantasy Legend
Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3
Yoshi's Cookie
BurgerTime Deluxe
Kirby's Dream Land

Excellent games:
Kirby's Dream Land 2
Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal
Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
Tetris
The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening

Perfect/Iconic Games:
Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow

My first handheld, and a true legend. This beast, utilizing dated hardware even for the time, proved for the first of many times that gamers care far less about performance than they do about quality game play. Its many competitors, from the Lynx to the Game Gear to the Wonderswan, came and went, leaving a footprint far less lasting than their technologically inferior ancestor. I feel like there's a ton more to experience here, too - this one may be going up in the rankings next time.

That will do it for the Middle Class. There's a lot of quality here, and a lot of potential for growth in most of these. But I can't bear to put the next few consoles in the Middle Class, so I'll arbitrarily make the cutoff here. See you soon! 

Monday, May 6, 2024

The Subjective Scientific reTROview Console Tier List - 2024 Edition: I'm Pretty Sure I Should Own This???

 


I am now competing with Square Enix for the most lengthy and confusing titles in the galaxy. They're still the odds on favorite, though. Anyway, last time on reTROview we discussed the lowest of the low, the trash tier. The proud denizens of the garbage included:

Sega Master System
Sega Saturn
PSP
PC Engine/Turbografx-16
Xbox
Wii
Wii U

Keep in mind that if your favorite console appears on the lower end of this tier list, it's not necessarily because it's a bad console. It's likely because I just don't know anything about it. Although, it could also be because it's a bad console. Our scoring system remains the same - each console gets 10 points for each perfect/iconic game, 5 points for each excellent game, and 1 point for each good game. For reference, the trash tier included systems ranging from 1 point to 16 points. Now we move into the next category...I'm pretty sure I should own this???


This is one of those situations where the hardware is just nicer than the software library. It had backwards compatibility, but not only was it backwards compatible, it also introduced color to your favorite Game Boy games! As a software library, though, I don't know much about it. It has several high fliers, though.

Game Boy Color (20 points):

Excellent games:

The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons
Wario Land 3
Mario Golf

It's early. But not really that early. I haven't had a ton of time to play my PS5, and 80% of the time I do, I'm catching up on PS4 games, which seem to go on sale super cheaply constantly. Little collector's hint - don't buy anything new unless you want to play it immediately. Several years later it'll be for sale on Amazon for $19.99 and it'll be just as fun.  It's a safe bet this one will sky up the rankings over the next decade, but I find it hard to see it beating the PS4.

PS5 (21 points):

Good games:
Astro's Playroom

Excellent games:
Marvel's Spider-Man: Miles Morales
NBA 2K
Marvel's Spider-Man 2
Hades


I play games on my mobile phone. I mostly do it because I always have it around, some of them are fun, and I'm bored. I don't know that I've played too many life-changing games on here.

Mobile Phones (32 points):

Good games:
Card Guardians
Luck Be a Landlord

Excellent games:
Candy Crush Soda Saga
Final Fantasy Record Keeper
Hearthstone
Pokemon Go
Terra Battle

And that's it! I can't stand to put the next system on this tier list in this tier, so we'll advance onward to the crowded Console Middle Class. See you soon!

-TRO 

Thursday, April 18, 2024

The Subjective Scientific reTROview Console Tier List - 2024 Edition: Trash Tier



This is the trash tier. Just because your favorite appears here doesn't mean the console is trash. It just means that in my experience, it's trash. If your console doesn't appear at all, by the way, that means that there's not a single game that I know of that I can confidently say that it's an 8.0 or higher. Without further ado, here are your proud denizens of the trash can!

Sega Master System (1 point):

Good Game:
Phantasy Star

This is the only Master System game I've ever played! It's pretty good.


Sega Saturn (1 point):

Good Games:
Nights into Dreams

Put that thing in the trash? It's beautiful! How dare I? This baby is just the right mix of expensive and hard to emulate to ensure that I never get the chance to experience the library. FPGA development is coming along, though. Maybe some day?


PSP (7 points):

Good Games:
Hot Shots Golf: Open Tee 2
Jeanne D'Arc

Excellent Games:
Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core

The PSP is a great little piece of hardware. I have two of them. Almost more than I have good games on this list. I actually use the PSP to play mostly ports and collections, and I don't consider any of those games to be PSP games.


PC Engine/Turbografx-16 (10 points):

Perfect/Iconic Games:
Castlevania: Rondo of Blood

I really need to get into this console! Rondo rules, but I know there's more out there. I'll poke around on my Pocket before too long. I'm feeling a shooter bug, and the only solution is to dive into the PC Engine, if the rumors are true.




Xbox (11 points):

Good Game:
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

Excellent Games:
Halo
Halo 2

This is an Xbox. It had a few great Halo games on it. There's probably more, too, but I am not certain.


Wii (15 points):

Good Games:
Donkey Kong County Returns
Mario Kart Wii
Punch-Out!!
Tiger Woods Golf
Wii Play

Excellent Games:
Wii Sports
Xenoblade Chronicles

This thing gave us a great month after Christmas when we received it. Wii Play and Wii Sports were very fun. I've probably touched one again less than 10 times since, particularly since I played Punch-Out!!Xenoblade, and Donkey Kong Country Returns on other systems.


Wii U (16 points):

Good Games:
Super Smash Bros. for Wii U

Excellent Games:
Super Mario Maker
New Super Mario Bros. U
Mario Kart 8

I have several more Wii U games to try, but there's actually several fantastic games on this console! Still probably not worth owning, especially since Mario Maker and Smash have been supplanted by their sequels and Kart has been ported to Switch.

And with that, my arbitrary cutoff for the trash tier has been reached. It hurts too much to put the next console in the trash tier, so I just won't. Come back soon for the I'm Pretty Sure I Should Own This tier!

- TRO